As the consulting firm grew, I hired more consultants, both full- and part-time. They were paid a percentage of billable time. In the boom times, I paid consultants 50% of our hourly fee. That was really too much. Most professional service firms do 1/3-1/3-1/3. One-third for the sale. One-third for service delivery, and one-third for overhead and profit. When our outplacement business slowed down because the economy improved, we reduced consultants' compensation to 40% of the hourly fee. Under this system, hardworking consultants could still earn $100,000-$125,000 per year.
In 1995 we had a windfall year. The price of oil was at an all-time low, and one of our oilfield clients in Houston laid off several thousand employees. I hired Nick Guiscard, a departing human resources executive from the client company, to work for us as a consultant. He delivered so much business we opened a Houston office. Our ads declared, "We tried to stay small--but failed."
February 19, 20—
Nick Guiscard
Vice President
CareerLab
11603 Banner Drive, STE 1600
Houston, TX 77500
Dear Nick,
This is a response to the events of the last several weeks, and to your e-mail requesting a change in your compensation.
As promised, I spoke with management consultant Mike Gaggenau about the issue. Mike helped me get the company started in the early 80s, and he has helped me with business planning issues ever since.
I don't know the details of Mark Hamilton's situation—if he's made a personal investment in the company—possibly he did. In any case, Roth & Gjelten is a 59-year-old company with 55 offices worldwide, and they're in an entirely different industry. Their fees are also double what ours are (30% of first year's compensation). They are certainly better capitalized than we are.
A more fair comparison would be with our competitors. How much do DBM consultants make? Contractors make $30-60K. Consultants earn $45-90K. At least that's what I'm hearing.
CareerLab is an S-Corporation. That means we don't retain earnings. We spend our revenues in salaries and improvements to the company. We don't build assets the way a C-Corporation does. This is perfectly normal; in fact, an S-Corporation with a high net worth is considered to be poorly managed. And this is how most professional firms are structured. They exist primarily to pay salaries to the professionals in the firm.
Regarding your salary: You said Mark Hamilton must have been a better negotiator than you. I don't think so. First of all, we don't know 100% of his contract—what pound of flesh they've extracted. I believe we only know part of the story.
by William S. Frank
|